A Brief History of Christmas Traditions Part 3

Char Close B_0002The American Christmas Victorian Style

I think the Victorian era is one of the most fun errors especially when discussing Christmas. In the United States where we is a blend of many cultures, and we showed little prejudice when came to adopting traditions. Neither did we spare any shame when it came to Americanizing them. Over the years some traditions were left behind and new ones popped up like favorite Christmas movies that we watch every single Christmas no matter how many times we’ve seen them.

In the last blog I asked if anyone knew the origins of Christmas stockings. I have the answer to that question below.

I hope you enjoy this 3rd blog in A Brief History of Christmas Traditions.

If someone asked me personally when the Victorian era started, I’d say between 1850 and 1870 and closer to the latter. Historians still argue this question. All arguments aside, Clement Clark Moore’s poem in 1822, A Visit From St. Nicholas, seemed to give all the nationalities of our country a common or similar Christmas Tradition. So this era seems to have birthed the “Victorian” Christmas.

Because of our staid Puritan ancestors, Americans were slower to adopt the Christmas customs known today. Puritans considered the celebration of Christ’s birth frivolous and heathen nonsense. Many held onto this belief into the late 1870s.

Southern states brought their customs over from England and kept them from colonial times through the Victorian era and in some cases they still exist.

And don’t forget the large Dutch population in the Northern colonies, especially New York. The Dutch had no qualms about celebrating the holidays in a jolly manner. They called their Santa by the name of St. Nicholas or St. Nick and it is from the Dutch we inherited the Christmas stocking.  

OldFashionToyssmall_8248609590Christmas rituals first got a toehold in New York with savvy merchants who were quick to realize their commercial value. German bakeries began staying open late to decorate their windows with red silk buntings and holly. Holiday shoppers could not resist the cakes, toys and candies displayed under glittering gas-jet lamps. Nor could they ignore the smells of cinnamon kuchens (cakes) and sweet almonds paste.

Also, by the 1870s Macy’s department store dressed their windows with large Christmas displays. One window displayed an amphitheater of wax, rag, bisque, and hand-painted porcelain dolls imported from Germany, France, Austria, Switzerland, and Bohemia. In another window, scenes from Uncle Tom’s Cabin were composed in a panorama with steam-driven movable parts.

By the 1880s Christmas’s conquest of the US was complete. Even Boston capitulated. Victorians now sent chromolithograph Christmas cards or painted their own. They filled silver paper cornucopias with candies. They decorated Christmas trees with apples, tangerines, walnuts dipped in egg white; strings of popcorn and cranberries; gold-foil “Dresdens” shaped as miniature stars and steamships, elves and fish and birds. [Taking the tree down was a fun activity for the children in the Victorian era as they were allowed to eat the eatable goodies on it.] Candles lit the trees and many a muslin dress caught fire!

Glass ornaments and icicles were introduced by the Germans around the mid-1880s.

Christmas preparations went beyond the stitching of new dresses, the gathering of holly and mistletoe and the stirring of the pudding. Handmade gifts, labored on months in advance, were often hung on the tree. There might be a pen-wiper in the shape of a water lily, a knitting bag worked with silk floss and matching fringe, a red rose potpourri, quince jam, and maybe a pair of embroidered bed slippers.

Christmas cards were addressed with nibbed pens and the aromas of scented paper in the stationer’s shop, inks and sealing wax filled the air. Brown or white paper wrappings were used and sealed shut with sealing wax.

Christmas Eve brought carolers singing Noel, While Shepherds Watched, Good King Wenceslas, Come All Ye Faithful and Silent Night. After singing the

carolers came into the hall for hot beer, punch, and pennies.

In many homes, Christmas Eve was the time when personal gifts were exchanged, while in others they waited until after church Christmas day. Children hung their stockings by the fireplace or over a bedpost.

Originally, the gifts under the tree were handmade and might include a sled or a carved toy made by father, a rag doll made by mother. A child might crochet the edges of a handkerchief.

Commercially made gifts became popular by the 1880’s. A child usually received only one store-bought toy — a far cry from what happens these days. It could have been a wind-up dancing bear, Logos, an early form of Scrabble, a precursor of Monopoly called Moneta, penny whistles, pull toys or stuffed animals. But the best gift of all was a father’s gift to his entire family. It might be a magic lantern with a four-wick oil lamp and a packet of twenty-five hand-tinted slides. The slides told a spooky story, with images of wicked gargoyles and saintly fairies cast upon a nine-foot-square white muslin screen.

After the gifts were discovered there was breakfast which was followed by church. The church was decorated with holly but almost never with mistletoe, as it was the badge of the Druid. By the 1880s, poinsettia plants were added to the array. After church, everyone headed back home to a mid-day Christmas dinner.

But first there was the grown-up gift exchange, and a glass of wine and seed-cake, providing this hadn’t taken place the night before. Then it was time to sit at the table with its brightly colored paper crackers, and good eats. The cracker, enjoyed in England as well, was brightly colored paper wrapped around a small gift and then twisted at each end. When the ends were tugged to open them, they made a cracking noise. Recently, these have reappeared in Christmas catalogs and specialty shops.

The main coarse depended upon ethnic background and where one lived. Anglophiles (popular term at the time describing one who greatly admired English ways) favored sirloin or beef or goose. But most Americans served turkey stuffed with oysters.

I still remember my grandmother serving oyster soup on Christmas Eve. While she was of French ancestry, her people had settled in the Pennsylvania Dutch area so I imagine, it was a family custom passed down.

If available and financially feasible, the table was loaded with all kinds of food. There might be a goose and/or ham too, sometimes all. Occasionally there were two turkeys, one boiled, and one roasted. There was also likely to be sausages, bacon, roast potatoes and whatever vegetables were available – turnips, baked squash, or some cabbage dish. Then there was homemade bread, preserves, mince pie or plum pudding.

Later in the afternoon, after a massive kitchen clean-up [some things never change] and the children’s naps, came the long-rehearsed Christmas program. Children in velvet breeches or dresses and high-buttoned shoes recited their memorized recitations. Family members played solos on the violin or piano, or composed plays, depicting scenes from the Bible or events in history.

To close this glorious day, the family gathered around the piano to sing Silent Night. Sometimes games would be played such as Blind Man’s Bluff and Hunt The Slipper. In some homes, this is when the mistletoe kissing was done too.

Some Victorian Menus in Different Locales

1773:  In England — boiled cod fish with fried soles, and around them oyster sauce, beef and wild duck.

1858:  Miners in the Rockys — Oysters, Pork, elk, antelope, buffalo, grizzly bear a` la mode, black mountain squirrel, prairie dog and mountain rats. Wine and whiskey was brought by wagon trains.

1863:  South Carolina Plantation — Oyster soup, boiled mutton, ham, boned turkey, wild ducks, partridges, plum pudding, burgundy, sherry, Madeira.


Alan Christmas cookies 1985It’s easy to see that most of the traditions established in the Victorian era are still well-known today if not always practiced. Lets hope that the message of “peace and goodwill toward men” is one tradition that is never forgotten in the hustle and bustle of today’s modern world.

In my next blog, part 4, I’ll give you a Christmas Time line that includes carols and other tidbits including some newer customs.

Okay, it’s share time. What family traditions do you have that have passed down through the generations? Do you know what nationality influenced your family traditions?


This entry was posted in History and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to A Brief History of Christmas Traditions Part 3

  1. Lyn Horner says:

    Sharla, you look like a Gibson Girl in that photo. Lovely! Your tree is also beautiful. You have done so much research on Christmas traditions and origins, it just amazes me. Thank you for sharing it with us!

  2. sharla says:

    Thanks Lynda. I love Christmas.

  3. Vicki Batman says:

    Wow, Sharla, lots of great research. This may sound a bit silly. When a small girl and returning from Christmas Eve party at my grandmother’s house, we would turn on the TV and watch “White Christmas” and sing all the songs. Every Christmas Eve, I still watch and tried to pass this on to my men, but alas, I don’t think that one stuck. Happy New Year, Happy Holidays, and Merry Christmas.

    • Sharla Rae says:

      I don’t think any Christmas tradition is silly. It’s the traditions that warm our hearts and what can be bad about that?! Merry Christmas and thank s for sharing your family tradition.

  4. Red says:

    I make Green Pups for Christmas breakfast, which is a tradition in my family, at least a couple generations. Green Pups are cream puffs. Hee-hee! For Boxing Day we have waffles all day long.

    I love your blog, Char! Merry Christmas!

  5. Janet Lane says:

    Entertaining post, Shar! Our family is very enthusiastic about traditions and historical origins, so I enjoyed every detail. One dear tradition our daughters enjoyed until they were in their twenties was the wall Advent Calendar. One of our au pairs introduced it, and we all fell in love with it. Below wooden wall decorations of Santa and his reindeer, I strung fat royal blue yarn that matched the Santa/reindeer decoration. It vaguely resembled a clothes line under the Santa. I tied it tightly because the weight of the presents made it sag a little.
    Using large white paper dinner napkins, I wrapped and numbered a small present for every day for each girl, and tied them with fat red and white yarn. Gifts were simple: personalized pencils, hair bows, and later Christmas ear rings, sparkly bracelets, concert tickets, etc. Ahh, memories!

    • sharla says:

      This sounds like a really fun tradition and it sounds like your daughters really enjoyed it. I’ve seen advent calendars and books in the store but now I’ll now I’ll take closer look. The idea of a present for each is really unique and I bet my grand kids would love it. Thanks for sharing and Merry Christmas!

  6. Sharla Rae says:

    My dear mother-in-law has tried and tried to teach me to make cream puffs. Alas, mine are sad imitations compared to hers. It’s so weird because I make lots of complicated deserts, by cream puffs have me stumped. 🙁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.